Burger Burger Fry Fry-Perfecting the Perfect Burger
Anyway, the wound is still fresh, but, in the intervening time, I managed to learn enough about burgers, and burgerism in general, that I now feel confident that I have it nailed. . .I can now report with some degree of confidence, that I have discovered how to wangle out a Perfect Burger. I’m not saying I’ve MADE it yet, but I know what it looks, smells, and tastes like. If I ever find one that I myself did not produce, I will pounce on it like it was Jerry and I was Tom, if you get the reference.
I want to be clear, I’m not talking about the specific places to FIND a perfect burger in Las Vegas. Just general ruminations on what makes a perfect burger. If you can extrapolate from these details, then I say Go Unto The God of Burgers, ye Pilgrim, and there give Thanks for The Burger. Amen. Non-religious or non-practicing Burger Lovers will just have to muddle along and go to their closest Supermarket.
Come with me, and let’s discover the Perfect Burger.
Let me say also that I believe the Perfect Burger is composed of beef. Yes, there are many tasty types of protein, almost all of which can be ground, which, to me, is what defines a Burger. By the way, if you’re looking for the history of the Burger and its derivation from Hamburg Steak, and why it’s technically different from Salisbury Steak, and so on, you’ll have to look elsewhere. Here we’re dealing with the Perfect Burger, and in Perfect Burger World, a burger is made of beef.
1. Fat Content and Beef Quality: This should be at least 20%. So, in terms of ideals, we’re looking for 80/20 beef. Usually, this is less expensive than superultradeluxe lean, which is a good thing. You already know, of course, that the purpose of having 80/20 beef is to insure that you have enough fat to both insulate the beef during cooking, and also to insure that it stays juicy and moist. Thermal shock causes the meat to be TOO tight (the proteins get wound too fast, and don’t relax as internal temperature rises), and too little fat means much higher evaporation of water molecules, meaning there won’t be enough juices to redistribute throughout the meat at the end of cooking.
In terms of quality, the better the quality, the better the taste overall. I think also that a blend of Sirloin and Chuck tastes better than just ground Sirloin (too lean) or just Chuck (not as flavourful, despite higher fat content). The problem here, of course, is to make sure that you maintain the proper fat/lean ratio. Unlike some, I don’t believe in double-grinding, and I don’t think a coarse grind improves flavour. Just a standard grind, one pass, ground while cold (so the fat doesn’t start melting). And don’t be too cheap. . .a great burger is worth the cost.
2. Size and Shape: This occupied me for a long time, but I think the best combination of size and shape is a 1/3 pound burger patty, in the shape of a square, with a divot in the middle. I can’t explain it to you, except to say that square patties seem to stay juicier. They also improve the LOOK of the burger, are easier to divot, easier to shape and form. . .a square is just better. Especially with shaping, you can stick them in the bottom of any square container, and, eh Voila, square burger! In terms of thickness, I like a good, thick burger, so probably at least 1 1/2-2 inches, but keep this in mind when you’re cooking, because your patty will contract inwards, becoming slightly thicker and losing some diameter. . .burgers tend to pull themselves toward the center, becoming more pucky. Not that it’s a bad thing, I’m just saying. The overall size of the burger is important. It should be somewhere between five and six inches across, depending on desired thickness. However, most people don’t like a patty that’s much smaller than about five inches, and, to be honest, a burger smaller across than this just SEEMS small. Wide and thick, with a little wiggle room on exactly HOW wide and exactly HOW thick. And, you can get too wide, and too thick. Stick with the limits identified above, and you should be fine.
3. Cooking the meat: Start with room-temperature meat, or as close as you can get. Season liberally with Salt and Pepper, on both sides, but don’t go crazy with the salt. Keep in mind also, that salt will begin to draw moisture to the surface, so don’t salt too long before you begin to cook. There’s a ton of disagreement on the best cooking method, but, in terms of the Perfect Burger, the winner from the standpoint of taste, is broiling. It’s also pretty easy, if tricky. However, a pan-fried burger can be pretty spectacular. Surprisingly, the most-preferred method, barbecuing, also created the worst-tasting burgers, even if your Brother-in-Law Phil is routinely acknowledged as the best BBQ griller in the whole damn subdivision.
So, your meat is standing by, having warmed to room temperature. You’ve seasoned it, and decided either to use the broiler or a pan. For a broiler, put the broiling pan in the oven, set to broil, and allow it to preheat. For pan-frying, prefer an iron skillet, if you have one, and set it to heating. An iron skillet should be preheated to just a smidge above medium high. Broilers, you only have one setting. . .not much drama here.
And we’re off. When your broiler pan or skillet are fully preheated, slide the patties into the working area, and off you go. You want three minutes per side for Medium-Rare burgers, and maybe a bit more. . .that’s why it’s important to divot the middle of the patty. . .as the patty cooks, the divot will fill-in, and the burger will cook more evenly (ever wonder why White Castle puts five holes in each of its patties? This here is why).
After you’ve flipped and cooked the patties on the other side for the same amount of time, cover the skillet if you’re pan frying, and turn off the broiler unit by dropping the oven temperature to 300, and return the burgers to the oven. You can check if you want, but if you’ve done everything right, your burgers should be Medium Rare to Medium, which is ideal for maxium juiciness and taste. You absolutely have the right to have a burger cooked more than medium-rare or medium, but, no matter how you FEEL about it, the truth is that such burgers are always less juicy and less flavourful.
And it’s not a scam or a game created by the Eat Raw Meat lobby to trick you; it’s fundamental physics. . .the proteins in meat get tighter and drier as they get more cooked. . .this forces water out of the matrix. The more you cook meat, the more of the fat is expressed and dispersed. . .fat carries flavour, so the less fat, the less flavour. Also, with beef some of the flavour components are water-soluble, and less water means less of these components.
When it comes to cheese, it seems that, no matter what, the addition of cheese improves a burger; it just TASTES better, almost independently of what type of cheese. However, it does seem like the stronger the flavour of the cheese, to a point, the better the burger tastes with it; i.e. Sharp Cheddar tastes better on a burger than Mild Cheddar; Jarlsberg or Aged Swiss seems to taste better than Baby Swiss, and so on.
Prepare your cheese (not TOO thick; about 3/8 of an inch is fine. . too thick and it falls off the burger, melts unevenly, and so on). Pull the burgers out of the broiler, or uncover the pan, place the cheese, and immediately return to their cubbyholes. . .you must absolutely cover the skillet, but resist the urge to BROIL the cheese onto the broiled burgers. . .broiled cheese doesn’t improve the flavour appreciably, and you’ll dry the meat out. Ideally, you should get to a bubbly consistently over the whole slice of cheese, but, from the standpoint of flavour, the best time is just when the cheese is melted enough to START bubbling. Pull the patties out and prepare for assembly.
It should be unnecessary to mention this, but mention it I shall: You MUST rest the meat after ending the cooking process, whether or not you add cheese. Patties must rest at least five minutes, and probably closer to ten, so that the juices can redistribute. I know it sounds like something all of us who cook meat made up, but it’s actually true. The WORST thing you can do, from the perspective of juiciness, is to serve SIZZLING hot meat (those of you who are sniggering are probably the worst offenders) to a guest. Just. don’t. do. it.
4. Composition of the Sandwich: Now may be the time to talk about various and sundry ingredients used to create your masterpiece. The range of toppings, dressings, and other -ings that can be applied to a burger are virtually endless, but there are some things that seem to be absolutely necessary to a perfect burger:
a. Cheese: We’ve already talked about this, but it’s important to make sure we’re clear. Almost everybody we’ve ever talked to too thinks cheese is necessary on the Perfect Burger. Oddly enough, even those who don’t particularly care for cheese think it’s required for a Perfect Burger. The cheeses most people think are appropriate are Sharp Cheddar, Swiss (ideally an aged or robust swiss), and, believe it or don’t, Bleu (by which is meant any of a variety of cheese in the “bleu” family, whether Maytag, Danish, Stilton, Roquefort, or any other type of cheese answering to the name of Blue).
b. Onion. Frankly, this surprised me, but most people think a Perfect Burger requires onion, on some level. The best taste is neither truly grilled, nor is it raw. The best taste seems to be a slice of raw, sweet onion (like Texas Sweet, Vidalia, Walla Walla, Maui, you get the drill), grilled for a few seconds on each side, and nothing else. Raw onion seems to be a little too “sharp” for the Perfect Burger, even among those who like raw onion (like yours truly). Grilled, sauteed, reduced, or in any other way, “adulterated” onions were also not preferred by most people. . .the comments indicated they felt the onion was “too cooked” to add much to the burger, and, also, it was felt that the onions became too sweet and not pungent enough. The next favourite is purple (italian sweet) onion, treated the same way.
c. Tomato: Another oddment. Not all that many people love the idea of tomato on a burger, which surprised me, because I love love love tomato. Nevertheless, almost everyone indicated that a Perfect Burger needed tomato, a fairly thick slice (about a third inch thick). It should be VERY ripe, almost too ripe, and sort of soft, and almost universally, the preferred tomato is the Beefsteak, which seems to have the right balance of flavour and texture.
d. Lettuce: People are torn about lettuce, no pun intended. It’s generally seen as an enhancement, but not a requirement. There’s an almost universal objection to whole leaf Iceberg, but people don’t generally mind a little shredded on the burger. Green Leaf Lettuce is vastly preferred, and is seen to be acceptable on the Perfect Burger. Your Correspondent loves lettuce, but doesn’t think it’s necessary on the Perfect Burger.
e. The Bun: Believe it or don’t, the bun is believed to be integral to the perfect burger. And, also surprisingly, it should be relatively soft, relatively thick, and somewhat sweet. It should also be grilled or toasted (toasted is preferred). It’s important to toast the bun in any event, to minimize breakthrough of the burger juices, which will make the bun soggy, and can break it down. Despite TV commercials to the contrary, people like a fairly big fluffy bun, easily smooshable, and overwhelmingly, the choice is either a Kaiser or Brioche style bun. No whole grain, sprouted, multi-grain, all-natural, you get the idea. Burgers were made for white, soft, slightly sweet buns. Toasted.
f. Sauces: It’s amazing how specific, and how particular, people are about the saucy components of their burgers. It is surprising how few people want much ketchup; I would have thought it was considered absolutely essential. Mustard too got a lot less pull than I had suspected it would. The actual perfect sauce topping seems to be a 50-50 mix of mayo and ketchup, ideally seasoned with salt, pepper, onion salt, worcestershire, and a tiny bit of garlic powder. This mixture was a hit with everyone at our burger tasting. Objectively, this topping seems to have enhanced the taste of the burger without obscuring it. Globs of ketchup, or even mustard applied in a thin layer, were seen to have obscured the “meaty” taste of the burger. Who knew? As we say in Utah, Fry Sauce rules.
g. Pickles: Pickles are either hands up or hands down. There’s almost no middle of the road. It seems to be exactly matched to the individual person’s like or dislike of an acid component to their burger, even though pickles also add an additional level of saltiness. Overall, pickles, while nummy, seem to obscure some of the taste of the meat. In other words, you may like the additional taste of pickles, but you’re sacrificing the meaty taste. At the end, pickles were not seen as necessary to the Perfect Burger. And by the way, no self-respecting burger should have sweet or bread and butter pickles on it. It’s just wrong.
5. Assembly: This turned out to be MUCH more important than anyone had realized. I won’t go into all the permutations. Suffice to say that this is how your burger should be assembled for maximum tastiness, even though it’s a little weird: Bottom bun, covered with your choice of sauce; Beef Patty, covered with dripping melted cheese; Onion slice, perfectly grilled; Tomato slice, ripe and juicy; lettuce if you must, but only in a single layer, and never piled on, even if it’s shredded; Top bun, covered with your choice of sauce. Sauces, mayo, mustard, whatever should never be drizzled or slathered on the condiment stack, no matter what McDonald’s and Burger King think. . .they do that because it’s FASTER, not because it’s better. If you want, you could add a dash of salt and pepper to the top of the condiment stack. . . some people think it raises the whole burger at least a couple degrees, others think it makes it too salty and peppery (we like it, but with salt/pepper on the tomato slice). However, it’s not necessary in order to make the Perfect Burger. But wait, there’s more. . . .
6. Accompaniments: Tricky. Some people are all about the fries, and there’s good evidence, and belief, that fries are the only natural and true side dish for a burger. Yet others believe that Onion Rings make a Perfect Burger even MORE Perfect. My own opinion is that fries, properly cooked, seasoned, and served, are the best accompaniment to the Perfect Burger. And by fries, I mean regular old fries made from regular old potatoes. While I love, love, LOVE Sweet Potato Fries, I think they’re too sweet to be helpful to the Perfect Burger. I feel the same way about Onion Rings. Really Great Onion Rings are one of the most perfect and delicious foods, on their own, in the whole universe. But the breading and the sweetness of the onions can interfere with the Perfect Burger.
Think of it like this. . .you’ve ordered the Perfect Pizza, but it’s completely appropriate to order a huge order of wings to go with it. And plenty of celery with Blue Cheese Dip. That’s how I feel about Onion Rings. . .it’s a go along, but not a true side dish for the Perfect Burger.
Well friends, there you are, the construction, support, and maintenance of The Perfect Burger. Okay, just the basic bare bones about the Perfect Burger. But it’s a start. If I may suggest, it might be fun for you to begin your own intensive set of experiments. . .use this little guide as a starting point, and find out how to make your own Perfect Burger. Making life better through beef, and serving humanity, all at the same time. . .how great is that?!
End Transmission.
